Thursday, December 9, 2010

Then We Came to the End

When Emmie first started talking about her paper I was not exactly sure where she was going to go with it. I haven’t read the book but based on the synopsis we were given at the start of the presentations breast cancer seemed like such a small aspect. I was not sure that she would be able to make a clear claim from that angle. As she continued to talk about her paper the whole idea came into focus. By the end of her presentation I was thinking to myself, “wow, that’s a really interesting idea.” She said she planned to look at the novel through the “lens of breast cancer” and that really had me thinking. I was really curious as to how it was all going to play out. I love the idea of having the emotions of a woman with breast cancer be a mirror for the emotions of the workers about to be laid off. Living in the constant fear of the unknown is easily linkable between the two groups. So, it is then a natural progression to examine what else might be created through this metaphor. If the boss was supposed to be this powerful, intimidating character and then she becomes a victim of this weakness then perhaps that can be reflected in the demise of this company.

The whole concept of books being metaphors for some greater idea really intrigues me. I never pick out these ideas on my own when I’m reading, but the later someone will point something out and it forces me to reexamine the story through this new idea. There are some people who always see some grand, deeper meaning in a novel. They think the authors are always writing things to stand for something else. Most of the time, I don’t buy it. I will admit that yes, it is possible that that was the author’s intention, but I do not think that every book (or even most books) are written with this motivation. Emmie’s idea of writing this paper with this frame is interesting. I do not think we have to believe that this was the author’s motivation, but rather we can accept the argument that Emmie makes and find a new way of reading the novel. I think that is the most interesting part of the whole concept. It will give the audience a fresh way to read the novel. And when they read this novel with these new intentions in mind it will give them a completely different experience.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Panel Discussions

Group 1- Without a Map (or a paddle)

Allie’s (I think?!) topic really struck an interest with me. I loved your line, “A welcome outcome to unwelcome exile”. Definitely use it in your paper, it’s catchyJ. I think your point that Hall was also experiencing a self-inflicted exile is important. Once she was rejected from her community she then went through her own exile as she was roaming the world. It seems like through this seclusion she was able to reach a point in her life where she could come back to the life she left behind. This self-inflicted exile allowed her to overcome the exile that was put upon her. Now, I didn’t read the book so I may be completely off base here so do what you wish with this. I think this kind of experience is not uncommon for many writers. Last semester I took a class called, “Writer’s in Exile” and we covered authors who were in both true exile as well as self-inflicted exile. Many of these authors needed that escape from their turbulent lives to be able to find the peace or clarity to write some of their most popular works. We looked at authors like F. Scott Fitzgerald, James Joyce, and D.H. Lawrence among others. This may take your paper in a completely different direction, but it might be interesting to look at authors who have written great novels out of an experience like this. What does the exile experience bring to the table when it comes to writing? I feel as though there would be critical analysis of this question that you could find to support an argument like this one.

I’m really interested in this book, guys! It is definitely going on the list. You know the list of books I would read if I wasn’t constantly reading books for school… that list. Some day. Good luck with your paper and I hope the argument works out clearly!