When Emmie first started talking about her paper I was not exactly sure where she was going to go with it. I haven’t read the book but based on the synopsis we were given at the start of the presentations breast cancer seemed like such a small aspect. I was not sure that she would be able to make a clear claim from that angle. As she continued to talk about her paper the whole idea came into focus. By the end of her presentation I was thinking to myself, “wow, that’s a really interesting idea.” She said she planned to look at the novel through the “lens of breast cancer” and that really had me thinking. I was really curious as to how it was all going to play out. I love the idea of having the emotions of a woman with breast cancer be a mirror for the emotions of the workers about to be laid off. Living in the constant fear of the unknown is easily linkable between the two groups. So, it is then a natural progression to examine what else might be created through this metaphor. If the boss was supposed to be this powerful, intimidating character and then she becomes a victim of this weakness then perhaps that can be reflected in the demise of this company.
The whole concept of books being metaphors for some greater idea really intrigues me. I never pick out these ideas on my own when I’m reading, but the later someone will point something out and it forces me to reexamine the story through this new idea. There are some people who always see some grand, deeper meaning in a novel. They think the authors are always writing things to stand for something else. Most of the time, I don’t buy it. I will admit that yes, it is possible that that was the author’s intention, but I do not think that every book (or even most books) are written with this motivation. Emmie’s idea of writing this paper with this frame is interesting. I do not think we have to believe that this was the author’s motivation, but rather we can accept the argument that Emmie makes and find a new way of reading the novel. I think that is the most interesting part of the whole concept. It will give the audience a fresh way to read the novel. And when they read this novel with these new intentions in mind it will give them a completely different experience.
Thursday, December 9, 2010
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Panel Discussions
Group 1- Without a Map (or a paddle)
Allie’s (I think?!) topic really struck an interest with me. I loved your line, “A welcome outcome to unwelcome exile”. Definitely use it in your paper, it’s catchyJ. I think your point that Hall was also experiencing a self-inflicted exile is important. Once she was rejected from her community she then went through her own exile as she was roaming the world. It seems like through this seclusion she was able to reach a point in her life where she could come back to the life she left behind. This self-inflicted exile allowed her to overcome the exile that was put upon her. Now, I didn’t read the book so I may be completely off base here so do what you wish with this. I think this kind of experience is not uncommon for many writers. Last semester I took a class called, “Writer’s in Exile” and we covered authors who were in both true exile as well as self-inflicted exile. Many of these authors needed that escape from their turbulent lives to be able to find the peace or clarity to write some of their most popular works. We looked at authors like F. Scott Fitzgerald, James Joyce, and D.H. Lawrence among others. This may take your paper in a completely different direction, but it might be interesting to look at authors who have written great novels out of an experience like this. What does the exile experience bring to the table when it comes to writing? I feel as though there would be critical analysis of this question that you could find to support an argument like this one.
I’m really interested in this book, guys! It is definitely going on the list. You know the list of books I would read if I wasn’t constantly reading books for school… that list. Some day. Good luck with your paper and I hope the argument works out clearly!
Allie’s (I think?!) topic really struck an interest with me. I loved your line, “A welcome outcome to unwelcome exile”. Definitely use it in your paper, it’s catchyJ. I think your point that Hall was also experiencing a self-inflicted exile is important. Once she was rejected from her community she then went through her own exile as she was roaming the world. It seems like through this seclusion she was able to reach a point in her life where she could come back to the life she left behind. This self-inflicted exile allowed her to overcome the exile that was put upon her. Now, I didn’t read the book so I may be completely off base here so do what you wish with this. I think this kind of experience is not uncommon for many writers. Last semester I took a class called, “Writer’s in Exile” and we covered authors who were in both true exile as well as self-inflicted exile. Many of these authors needed that escape from their turbulent lives to be able to find the peace or clarity to write some of their most popular works. We looked at authors like F. Scott Fitzgerald, James Joyce, and D.H. Lawrence among others. This may take your paper in a completely different direction, but it might be interesting to look at authors who have written great novels out of an experience like this. What does the exile experience bring to the table when it comes to writing? I feel as though there would be critical analysis of this question that you could find to support an argument like this one.
I’m really interested in this book, guys! It is definitely going on the list. You know the list of books I would read if I wasn’t constantly reading books for school… that list. Some day. Good luck with your paper and I hope the argument works out clearly!
Wednesday, November 24, 2010
Friday, November 19, 2010
Note...
The formatting of the citations was completely screwed up in the posting of the proposal.... I apologize.
Proposal
Trans-Sister Radio challenges our view of gender roles. American society has very strict social constraints surrounding gender. We see these areas as very divided. Males and females each have a very specific way that they are supposed to act. There are certain jobs that are associated with certain genders both in the work force and in the home. At a very young age children are being conditioned to view gender in this very specific way. This book, however, forces us to reexamine those things. As Dana is coming to terms with his differences he is recognizing all of the places where he does not fit into the world as a man. He does not do the things he is “supposed to” do. He does not act the way he is “supposed to” act. And he does not like the things he is “supposed to” like. Dana must comes to terms with this and understand what it means for him. In this process he has to redefine his own set of gender rules. In Trans-Sister Radio society’s predetermined gender roles influence Dana’s decision to have the sexual reassignment surgery and then he is forced to redefine them in his own life.
The research I have compiled up until now will serve to create a picture of how Dana interprets gender roles. Using the book I will illustrate how Dana has to reshape some of those constraints to fit into his new lifestyle. He has not lived his life as a biological woman and in the years before the surgery and then after it as well he has to attempt to reshape the preconceptions society has surrounding gender.
Blume, Libby Balter and Thomas Blume. “Toward a Dialectical Model of Family Gender
Discourse: Body, Indentity, and Sexuality”. Journal of Marriage and Family. 65.
Nov. 2003. p 785-794.
This focuses on gender roles within a family. Blume and Blume report that there is a typical structure as to how families operate and there are gender roles that are repeated. They talk about how this ideal is perpetuated in the children of the family. Children are learning these social structures through what they see in their homes. From this young age children are seeing what mothers do and what fathers do. This transfers onto a broader societal scale and what women do and what men do. I can see this working to my paper in the way that Dana saw himself growing up. He knew from a young age that his feelings were more connected to that of what women were supposed to feel. Through this conditioning that all children go through Dana knew that he did not fit into society’s norms and from there felt ostracized.
Kane, Emily W. “’No Way My Boys Are Going to be like That!’ Parents’ Responses to
Children’s Gender Nonconformity”. Gender and Society. 20:2 April 2006 p 149-176.
This article is made up of parental interviews and shows the reactions to children not conforming to the gender roles. This interesting piece demonstrates how parents have a much easier time adapting to their daughters who do not fit into the stereotypes. When it is the sons who are do not conform the reaction is much different. There is also a focus on how heterosexual fathers have extreme aversion to this kind of behavior from their sons and will try and combat it through excessive demonstration on their part. This will tie into Dana’s parents reaction to his lifestyle. They have a very difficult time accepting that Dana is not the son that they may have imagined having. His father especially reacts by completely shutting down once he sees nothing can be done.
Marini, Margaret Mooney. “Sex and Gender: What Do We Know?”. Sociological Forum. 5:1
1990.
This is a direct explanation of the differences between men and women. It discusses the different areas in which men and women differ; biologically, socially, and societal roles. It also gives an explanation as to how men and women have evolved to fit into these stereotypes because of the roles they play in society, specifically the labor roles. This will give me a basis for what is expected within our world. It will provide concrete back up to what I already understand about what we experience every day due to gender differences.
Ridgeway, Cecelia L. and Shelley J. Correll. “Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical
Perspective on Gender Beliefs and Social Relations”. Gender and Society. 18:4.
Aug 2004. P 510-531.
This is an interesting article in that it considers the gender roles as they stand in relation to others. Ridgeway and Correll state that gender roles exist because of how people see themselves. And people construct their feelings about themselves in comparison to other people. Through the interactions with others a person constructs an understanding of themselves and consequently of their gender. I can see this fitting into Dana’s need to have the surgery. He cannot see himself as fitting into the role that other people expect of him if he does not have the surgery. The surgery will make it possible for his feelings to fit in with the expectations that people set for him.
Risman, Barbara J. “Gender as a Social Structure: Theory Wrestling with Activism”. Gender and
Society. 18:4. Aug 2004. P 429-450.
Risman argues that gender differences are not really based on biology or “individual learning” it is really based on the social structures. The expectations created by society surrounding gender are what create these differences and without them the resulting gender roles would be very different. Gender is in all “social processes of everyday life and social organizations” therefore it these gender roles cannot be avoided. It is inevitable that people will develop these differences. Dana would be a counterexample to this argument in that while he is biologically male he has fought against the social expectations of that gender. At the same time he has had to take part in many of these expectations prior to the surgery. So, he really stands a social contradiction on his own.
The research I have compiled up until now will serve to create a picture of how Dana interprets gender roles. Using the book I will illustrate how Dana has to reshape some of those constraints to fit into his new lifestyle. He has not lived his life as a biological woman and in the years before the surgery and then after it as well he has to attempt to reshape the preconceptions society has surrounding gender.
Blume, Libby Balter and Thomas Blume. “Toward a Dialectical Model of Family Gender
Discourse: Body, Indentity, and Sexuality”. Journal of Marriage and Family. 65.
Nov. 2003. p 785-794.
This focuses on gender roles within a family. Blume and Blume report that there is a typical structure as to how families operate and there are gender roles that are repeated. They talk about how this ideal is perpetuated in the children of the family. Children are learning these social structures through what they see in their homes. From this young age children are seeing what mothers do and what fathers do. This transfers onto a broader societal scale and what women do and what men do. I can see this working to my paper in the way that Dana saw himself growing up. He knew from a young age that his feelings were more connected to that of what women were supposed to feel. Through this conditioning that all children go through Dana knew that he did not fit into society’s norms and from there felt ostracized.
Kane, Emily W. “’No Way My Boys Are Going to be like That!’ Parents’ Responses to
Children’s Gender Nonconformity”. Gender and Society. 20:2 April 2006 p 149-176.
This article is made up of parental interviews and shows the reactions to children not conforming to the gender roles. This interesting piece demonstrates how parents have a much easier time adapting to their daughters who do not fit into the stereotypes. When it is the sons who are do not conform the reaction is much different. There is also a focus on how heterosexual fathers have extreme aversion to this kind of behavior from their sons and will try and combat it through excessive demonstration on their part. This will tie into Dana’s parents reaction to his lifestyle. They have a very difficult time accepting that Dana is not the son that they may have imagined having. His father especially reacts by completely shutting down once he sees nothing can be done.
Marini, Margaret Mooney. “Sex and Gender: What Do We Know?”. Sociological Forum. 5:1
1990.
This is a direct explanation of the differences between men and women. It discusses the different areas in which men and women differ; biologically, socially, and societal roles. It also gives an explanation as to how men and women have evolved to fit into these stereotypes because of the roles they play in society, specifically the labor roles. This will give me a basis for what is expected within our world. It will provide concrete back up to what I already understand about what we experience every day due to gender differences.
Ridgeway, Cecelia L. and Shelley J. Correll. “Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical
Perspective on Gender Beliefs and Social Relations”. Gender and Society. 18:4.
Aug 2004. P 510-531.
This is an interesting article in that it considers the gender roles as they stand in relation to others. Ridgeway and Correll state that gender roles exist because of how people see themselves. And people construct their feelings about themselves in comparison to other people. Through the interactions with others a person constructs an understanding of themselves and consequently of their gender. I can see this fitting into Dana’s need to have the surgery. He cannot see himself as fitting into the role that other people expect of him if he does not have the surgery. The surgery will make it possible for his feelings to fit in with the expectations that people set for him.
Risman, Barbara J. “Gender as a Social Structure: Theory Wrestling with Activism”. Gender and
Society. 18:4. Aug 2004. P 429-450.
Risman argues that gender differences are not really based on biology or “individual learning” it is really based on the social structures. The expectations created by society surrounding gender are what create these differences and without them the resulting gender roles would be very different. Gender is in all “social processes of everyday life and social organizations” therefore it these gender roles cannot be avoided. It is inevitable that people will develop these differences. Dana would be a counterexample to this argument in that while he is biologically male he has fought against the social expectations of that gender. At the same time he has had to take part in many of these expectations prior to the surgery. So, he really stands a social contradiction on his own.
Thursday, November 11, 2010
Listener- "Slut"
In the poem, “Slut” the listener seems to be a general audience. Gottlieb is speaking to anyone who has ever used the term slut. She is speaking up against the term, and explaining how she has fought against it. And at the same time she is speaking to whoever has called HER a slut. She not only defends the term, but she also defends herself. She explains what the word has done to her, and how has she been impacted by the word. While she uses the term in a broad sense and explains its overall impact she is always speaking with “I”. Clearly she is approaching it from a personal experience. This is why I can see the listener as both a general audience and her own personal audience.
From the way she speaks, it seems like she wants the world to know that this word takes away all of the other aspects of her. To use the same quote I used last time: “from the way i look/ after i’m split open/ you’d never know:/ i was born a baby.” She goes on to list all of the aspects of her that are stripped away when this term is used. When she is split open by this word everything else becomes less important. Her childhood innocence disappears when she is known as the slut. This poem is written to anyone who has called her, or anyone else, a slut. This is the power that this word has. It has the power to define a woman. Once this label has been applied then suddenly that is all that anyone can see. I believe Gottlieb sees this poem as a kind of public service announcement to whoever has used this word against someone. She wants to make clear the impact that it can have.
From the way she speaks, it seems like she wants the world to know that this word takes away all of the other aspects of her. To use the same quote I used last time: “from the way i look/ after i’m split open/ you’d never know:/ i was born a baby.” She goes on to list all of the aspects of her that are stripped away when this term is used. When she is split open by this word everything else becomes less important. Her childhood innocence disappears when she is known as the slut. This poem is written to anyone who has called her, or anyone else, a slut. This is the power that this word has. It has the power to define a woman. Once this label has been applied then suddenly that is all that anyone can see. I believe Gottlieb sees this poem as a kind of public service announcement to whoever has used this word against someone. She wants to make clear the impact that it can have.
Thursday, November 4, 2010
Slut
“Slut” by Daphne Gottleib. Since this was such a focus for today’s class I followed the trend and am turning to it for this blog. I have more to say than what came up in discussion so here we go. I could probably talk about the speaker of this poem for hours and hours, we certainly gave it a go in class. But for the purposes of this post I’ll talk about the lineation of the poem. I think what Gottlieb does with this piece is very powerful. The she has the stanzas divided and the lines themselves alternatingly end-stopped and enjambed. They way that she puts these lines together allows for the flow of the poem to be somewhat forced upon you. As I read through the poem multiple times I was able to catch on the line breaks. If you read it as it is intended, paying attention to punctuation and line breaks then it seems as though someone is reading it to you. In this passage the colon is especially important,
“from the way i look
after i’m split open
you’d never know:
i was born a baby.”
The placement of this colon is where the poem begins to take a turn. At this point she begins to list all of the things that make her “human” she is defining herself in terms greater than her sexuality. Gottleib is reminding the reader that she is not just a slut, but she is all of these “normal” things as well. She is attempting to become more than the label. The line breaks show the reader that something is changing. Then after this, when she is listing these things that describe her she uses short, choppy sentences. “i want to be a nurse.” “my favorite color is blue.” I think this a very successful way of presenting this poem. It is as though she is speaking through this poem. It reads like speech, and that is why she is successful. She is speaking out against this label of “slut” so by organizing the poem like speech her point comes across.
“from the way i look
after i’m split open
you’d never know:
i was born a baby.”
The placement of this colon is where the poem begins to take a turn. At this point she begins to list all of the things that make her “human” she is defining herself in terms greater than her sexuality. Gottleib is reminding the reader that she is not just a slut, but she is all of these “normal” things as well. She is attempting to become more than the label. The line breaks show the reader that something is changing. Then after this, when she is listing these things that describe her she uses short, choppy sentences. “i want to be a nurse.” “my favorite color is blue.” I think this a very successful way of presenting this poem. It is as though she is speaking through this poem. It reads like speech, and that is why she is successful. She is speaking out against this label of “slut” so by organizing the poem like speech her point comes across.
Thursday, October 21, 2010
Project Proposal
Proposal
Gender: Are there two definitive genders anymore?
For this paper I would like to explore the idea of gender. Our book, Trans-Sister Radio by Chris Bohjalian addresses this issue head on. Through Dana’s exploration of his gender dysphoria he has to redefine his own gender. As he is going through the process he begins to pay close attention to the differences in how men and women act. He recognizes that there are inherent differences, both physically and how they are perceived by society. While he is in transition, he is aware of these things because they will affect him. He is attempting to learn the “rules” that come with womanhood through his observation of how women act.
My goal with this research would be to explore how the genders have been portrayed. Is there a common picture that exists through time? Or has the idea of female vs. male changed over time. I would argue that the depiction of genders has changed. Presently, gender is something that is easier to play with. In popular culture it is much more common to see gender be represented in various ways. For a male to be more effeminate or for a female to carry herself in more of a masculine manner is not as strange a sight. This has become a part of our culture now, and I expect that it has become more of a written about subject.
I anticipate that I will see more blending of gender than what existed in literature of the past. Historically, the gender roles were well defined. People knew their place and rarely wavered, but now that it is not the case, and I expect the research will show that.
Gender: Are there two definitive genders anymore?
For this paper I would like to explore the idea of gender. Our book, Trans-Sister Radio by Chris Bohjalian addresses this issue head on. Through Dana’s exploration of his gender dysphoria he has to redefine his own gender. As he is going through the process he begins to pay close attention to the differences in how men and women act. He recognizes that there are inherent differences, both physically and how they are perceived by society. While he is in transition, he is aware of these things because they will affect him. He is attempting to learn the “rules” that come with womanhood through his observation of how women act.
My goal with this research would be to explore how the genders have been portrayed. Is there a common picture that exists through time? Or has the idea of female vs. male changed over time. I would argue that the depiction of genders has changed. Presently, gender is something that is easier to play with. In popular culture it is much more common to see gender be represented in various ways. For a male to be more effeminate or for a female to carry herself in more of a masculine manner is not as strange a sight. This has become a part of our culture now, and I expect that it has become more of a written about subject.
I anticipate that I will see more blending of gender than what existed in literature of the past. Historically, the gender roles were well defined. People knew their place and rarely wavered, but now that it is not the case, and I expect the research will show that.
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Blog Reflection
Wow, I whine a lot. I think I’ve always kind of known this about myself. When I do not know exactly what to say I will pick something to complain about or comment on. This is an obnoxious habit. Who wants to listen to my whiney self all day? I’m sure none of you! This being said... I can find some good in this. Reading back through my posts I see the common theme that I tend to pick things that bother me. When I am uncomfortable I produce quality writing. When I can get fired up about something, I produce quality writing. I think this can be true of many people. There needs to be some passion behind the writing, some fire. Otherwise it is simply flat, black words on a square white sheet. Except in this case it is flat, blue words on neon green background. Which I’m realizing may be difficult to read… my apologies. But seriously, I believe that strong writing comes from a strong feeling, and I think that is a major theme for my blogs. I spin the question in a way that allows me to “complain” or criticize something.
Another track that I tend to take is finding the personal side to things. Not just in terms of my own experiences, but rather finding out the personal within the readings we do. I want to relate to people, and I want to understand them. Often in my posts I am attempting to understand why people do what they do. Most times I cannot figure it out, but I try. In my 1 Dead in Attic post I am attempting to understand how someone could think it was acceptable to leave their mess for someone else. “It’s easier to throw your trash outside, it’s easier to dump your refrigerator down the street so you don’t have to look at it, but then someone else does. It is this idea that passing off your own problems to someone else is not the way to go.” I try to do this again in my September 11th post. I talk about why people may need a memorial in order to move on with their lives. In the Falling Man post I talk about why I don’t like the book because I cannot connect with the characters. I miss being able to understand them and when I cannot understand them then I cannot find that connection.
Clearly I enjoy connection with other people, both in life and in my reading! The writing in my posts allows me to see this clearly. When I am not connected or invested in what I am writing about then my writing is boring, and I think you can pick out which posts were which for me. At least I can… And I can see now that what I am often connected to are the human relationships and how I can relate to the characters. I like to be able to feel what they are feeling and experience these things with them, and when this is difficult then the reading is difficult.
Another track that I tend to take is finding the personal side to things. Not just in terms of my own experiences, but rather finding out the personal within the readings we do. I want to relate to people, and I want to understand them. Often in my posts I am attempting to understand why people do what they do. Most times I cannot figure it out, but I try. In my 1 Dead in Attic post I am attempting to understand how someone could think it was acceptable to leave their mess for someone else. “It’s easier to throw your trash outside, it’s easier to dump your refrigerator down the street so you don’t have to look at it, but then someone else does. It is this idea that passing off your own problems to someone else is not the way to go.” I try to do this again in my September 11th post. I talk about why people may need a memorial in order to move on with their lives. In the Falling Man post I talk about why I don’t like the book because I cannot connect with the characters. I miss being able to understand them and when I cannot understand them then I cannot find that connection.
Clearly I enjoy connection with other people, both in life and in my reading! The writing in my posts allows me to see this clearly. When I am not connected or invested in what I am writing about then my writing is boring, and I think you can pick out which posts were which for me. At least I can… And I can see now that what I am often connected to are the human relationships and how I can relate to the characters. I like to be able to feel what they are feeling and experience these things with them, and when this is difficult then the reading is difficult.
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Trans-Sister Radio
I hope you are all enjoying the beginning of this book. As I have started it again I am remembering more of the details of the story and it's making me self conscious about my selection! Be honest, if you hate it I will not be offended. But I hope you like it...
The complicated storyline of this book gives it a lot of tangled meaning. The issues rest on many different levels and it leaves a lot of room for opinions. I really like the daughter, Carly in this book. She acts as the main narrator with her radio transcripts between chapters, but the story is really told from all parties involved. Carly's voice is one that really speaks to me. Right in the beginning the reader is given the end of the story, so right away I started piecing together the middle. Carly is the unbelievably calm character through all of this. I cannot imagine a life changing event like this one happen in my family. It is difficult to predict how I would react in this situation. For me, my parents are still married so I never experienced either of my parents with another partner. That alone would take a lot of getting used to for me. Then for my mother to fall in love with someone with gender dysphoria is something I cannot even imagine. It would change my life in ways I can only imagine. I think that for these reasons Carly's character really resonates with me. Her life is changed by this in such a large way and she is able to remain this strong, resilient young woman. These are very respectable qualities to have in any person, but for someone who has lived this life it is that much more impressive. She seems to be the symbol for all of the things that Dana needs in his world. He has come across boundaries based on his situation put up by the close minded people in his world, and I think people like Carly are what is missing. In segments taken from the radio transcripts it is easier to see how much Carly has been changed from the whole experience. After living it she is now able to reflect on it and use that knowledge to spread awareness and educate more people. All of these things together are what make Carly such a stand alone character for me.
The complicated storyline of this book gives it a lot of tangled meaning. The issues rest on many different levels and it leaves a lot of room for opinions. I really like the daughter, Carly in this book. She acts as the main narrator with her radio transcripts between chapters, but the story is really told from all parties involved. Carly's voice is one that really speaks to me. Right in the beginning the reader is given the end of the story, so right away I started piecing together the middle. Carly is the unbelievably calm character through all of this. I cannot imagine a life changing event like this one happen in my family. It is difficult to predict how I would react in this situation. For me, my parents are still married so I never experienced either of my parents with another partner. That alone would take a lot of getting used to for me. Then for my mother to fall in love with someone with gender dysphoria is something I cannot even imagine. It would change my life in ways I can only imagine. I think that for these reasons Carly's character really resonates with me. Her life is changed by this in such a large way and she is able to remain this strong, resilient young woman. These are very respectable qualities to have in any person, but for someone who has lived this life it is that much more impressive. She seems to be the symbol for all of the things that Dana needs in his world. He has come across boundaries based on his situation put up by the close minded people in his world, and I think people like Carly are what is missing. In segments taken from the radio transcripts it is easier to see how much Carly has been changed from the whole experience. After living it she is now able to reflect on it and use that knowledge to spread awareness and educate more people. All of these things together are what make Carly such a stand alone character for me.
Thursday, September 30, 2010
Brutal Botero
These paintings by Fernando Botero depict an event that is bound to strike up emotion. These paintings are based on an actual occurrence. This in itself is a very common thing, but because real photographs also came out of this event that seems to make the paintings a bit more real as well. I think in regular historical paintings it is easy to distances oneself from the fact that it is a true event. We think that the artist has come up with this image from his or her mind. For us as viewers this allows us to believe only what we wish to believe, but not with these pieces. The slides state that Botero has said that these images are what he has pieced together from news coverage, and that these are not based on actual photographs. However, those photographs do exist. It may not be an exact replica of the Botero?s painting but it is very similar. We have been exposed to these images of real people being treated in this horrifying manner, and because of that it is much harder to look at this artwork and not see it as real life.
In the last picture of the slideshow, Botero has shown the mass of partially and fully naked bodies piled on top of one another. The men lie there without a fight. They look like utter victims of this painful humiliation. The way that Botero has organized the bodies is common throughout all of the actual photographs that came out of this event as well. It is chaotic and childish. There is no system to it all and it appears to be done without purpose. What I mean by purpose is that there is no organization to the piling of the men, as there may have been if the men were dead bodies. On the other hand there is definitely a purpose to the humiliation being caused. This is done knowingly and menacingly.
In regards to the cartoonish aspect of the painting, I think it serves the overall confusion shown in this painting. The prisoners look as if they have given up the fight and have given up trying. They lie lifeless and calm. How could anyone be in that state while this was happening to them? That I think is emphasized by the cartoon figures. It is unbelievable that this could be true, and yet at the same time we all know it to be true.
In the last picture of the slideshow, Botero has shown the mass of partially and fully naked bodies piled on top of one another. The men lie there without a fight. They look like utter victims of this painful humiliation. The way that Botero has organized the bodies is common throughout all of the actual photographs that came out of this event as well. It is chaotic and childish. There is no system to it all and it appears to be done without purpose. What I mean by purpose is that there is no organization to the piling of the men, as there may have been if the men were dead bodies. On the other hand there is definitely a purpose to the humiliation being caused. This is done knowingly and menacingly.
In regards to the cartoonish aspect of the painting, I think it serves the overall confusion shown in this painting. The prisoners look as if they have given up the fight and have given up trying. They lie lifeless and calm. How could anyone be in that state while this was happening to them? That I think is emphasized by the cartoon figures. It is unbelievable that this could be true, and yet at the same time we all know it to be true.
Thursday, September 23, 2010
Falling Man
It is safe to say that Falling Man is not high on my list of favorite books; it’s not even making the list. There is something about this book that I just cannot quite put my finger on. I never get excited to read this book, and it is very rare that I even am highly invested while in the process of reading it. I cannot connect to any of the characters in the book. Typically, when I read a book that I enjoy I become very attached to the characters. I feel for them or with them, or I hate them, but I have a reaction. This book does none of that for me. The only reason I have any true emotions connected to this book is because it deals with a topic that affected us all as Americans. So, because I automatically feel something regarding that topic I get that same feeling regarding this book. However, as far as anything regarding the characters or their stories I feel nothing.
The conclusion that I have come to about this is that I am struggling with the style. The way DeLillo has structured this novel makes it very inaccessible to me. These characters are still strangers and the events of their lives are distant. I cannot make myself care, or feel anything at all, about the people in this book. The way that the story jumps from one seemingly meaningless moment to another forwards and backwards in time just leaves me wanting more, or wanting it to end. But, what confuses me is that I’m still not exactly sure that it is only the style that I have an issue with. What is it exactly that makes this book such a shell? I do feel that there is a purpose to this style. Perhaps DeLillo is attempting to reconstruct the true emotions that people in New York City were experiencing right after the attacks, but I’m not entirely sure this is true. I can see that he may have had a goal in mind with this story, but I think that it may be going over my head. It is certainly lacking something for me, and I’m still not exactly sure what it is. Any help?
The conclusion that I have come to about this is that I am struggling with the style. The way DeLillo has structured this novel makes it very inaccessible to me. These characters are still strangers and the events of their lives are distant. I cannot make myself care, or feel anything at all, about the people in this book. The way that the story jumps from one seemingly meaningless moment to another forwards and backwards in time just leaves me wanting more, or wanting it to end. But, what confuses me is that I’m still not exactly sure that it is only the style that I have an issue with. What is it exactly that makes this book such a shell? I do feel that there is a purpose to this style. Perhaps DeLillo is attempting to reconstruct the true emotions that people in New York City were experiencing right after the attacks, but I’m not entirely sure this is true. I can see that he may have had a goal in mind with this story, but I think that it may be going over my head. It is certainly lacking something for me, and I’m still not exactly sure what it is. Any help?
Thursday, September 16, 2010
Remembering September 11th
Well, after that cheery class discussion here’s some more cheer:
The issue of how a tragic event should be remembered will always be there. Whenever an event like September 11th happens it creates uproar of emotions. These emotions are coming from people with varying degrees of connection to the situation. The terrorist attacks that happened on that day were something that shook the United States as a whole. Every citizen had some reaction. It would have been impossible not to, although I do not doubt that it was the most difficult for people who were immediately affected. For those who lost loved ones and assisted in the rescues and lived that moment in New York City, Washington DC, and Pennsylvania it was a completely different experience. It is one that I will never be able to comprehend, and honestly I hope that I never have an experience similar to that. But it is because of all of this emotion that we are having a hard time moving on from the experience. It is for that same reason that we are so split about the tactfulness of pictures such as “The Falling Man”. They stand as constant reminders of what we all felt on that Tuesday and in the days and months and even years to follow.
I think that an important step in moving forward from September 11, 2001 is if we are able to decide on some way to memorialize the event. To do nothing is to do a disservice to all of those who lost their lives on that day. We must do something. The woman quoted in the article felt that it would only stand as a constant reminder of a horrific event. Well, yes. That is exactly what it would be. It would be a reminder for us all of that day. Now, I do not think that we should all go around crying about this terrible day in history, but I do think it is important to have a place to visit. For many of us we were not directly connected to someone who died, but we are all American and it was America that was attacked on that day. So if for nothing else, then the memorial will act as a physical place that we can go and be reminded of those events. It will be a place where we can pay our respects to all of the men and women who lost their lives that day. And maybe when a place such as this exists it will provide enough healing that we will be able to in some ways move on.
The issue of how a tragic event should be remembered will always be there. Whenever an event like September 11th happens it creates uproar of emotions. These emotions are coming from people with varying degrees of connection to the situation. The terrorist attacks that happened on that day were something that shook the United States as a whole. Every citizen had some reaction. It would have been impossible not to, although I do not doubt that it was the most difficult for people who were immediately affected. For those who lost loved ones and assisted in the rescues and lived that moment in New York City, Washington DC, and Pennsylvania it was a completely different experience. It is one that I will never be able to comprehend, and honestly I hope that I never have an experience similar to that. But it is because of all of this emotion that we are having a hard time moving on from the experience. It is for that same reason that we are so split about the tactfulness of pictures such as “The Falling Man”. They stand as constant reminders of what we all felt on that Tuesday and in the days and months and even years to follow.
I think that an important step in moving forward from September 11, 2001 is if we are able to decide on some way to memorialize the event. To do nothing is to do a disservice to all of those who lost their lives on that day. We must do something. The woman quoted in the article felt that it would only stand as a constant reminder of a horrific event. Well, yes. That is exactly what it would be. It would be a reminder for us all of that day. Now, I do not think that we should all go around crying about this terrible day in history, but I do think it is important to have a place to visit. For many of us we were not directly connected to someone who died, but we are all American and it was America that was attacked on that day. So if for nothing else, then the memorial will act as a physical place that we can go and be reminded of those events. It will be a place where we can pay our respects to all of the men and women who lost their lives that day. And maybe when a place such as this exists it will provide enough healing that we will be able to in some ways move on.
Friday, September 10, 2010
1 Dead in Attic
A huge theme that I’ve seen running through this book is the idea that we must take responsibility for ourselves. Chris Rose comments that the people of New Orleans must look out for one another. He sees that there are many opportunities to fall into bad habits. It’s easier to throw your trash outside, it’s easier to dump your refrigerator down the street so you don’t have to look at it, but then someone else does. It is this idea that passing off your own problems to someone else is not the way to go. Rose is saying that in a situation such as the one they are in there needs to be some responsibility taken by all. Help who you can and accept help when you need it, but do not add to the already dismal situation.
The two columns “Civil Unrest” (101) and “Not in My Pothole” (160) both look at this issue of how the neighborhood and Rose react to these situations. In “Civil Unrest” the neighborhood bands together after a renegade refrigerator bandit strikes on their street. Their anger is sparked because the trash collectors had just come through. They had finally gotten their street back to some degree of normalcy. It was their small oasis in the chaos and this guy ruins it. Rose describes it like this, “We could see our curbs and sidewalks for the first time since the hurricane. The place was swept spotless. It was a time for celebration. Except for that damn smelly fridge they left on the corner, just like we said they would.” (103) Even after explaining to the man that his fridge wouldn’t be taken by clean-up crews he left it. It was this act of outright disrespect towards him and his fellow residents that really gets to Rose, and I don’t see how it couldn’t get to him.
In “Not in My Pothole” is a similar situation minus the personal touch. In this column someone has abandoned a dishwasher within the depths of a pothole. This is another instance of passing one’s own problems onto the problems of the group. Now, I completely understand and even encourage asking for help when it is needed. However, this does not fall under that category. This is an example of some person’s feeble attempt to make things better for himself at the expense of his neighbors. In Rose’s words, “Or maybe it was just the careless act of a common punk and now it’s somebody else’s problem, not his.” (161). Having this kind of attitude in any situation, let alone one as grave as this, does not solve anything.
Chris Rose echoes this idea throughout many of his columns. People need to step up and do their part to help make the situation just that little bit better. They are all in this terrible situation together and they need to lean on one another. If they don’t have each other then who else will they be able to turn to?
The two columns “Civil Unrest” (101) and “Not in My Pothole” (160) both look at this issue of how the neighborhood and Rose react to these situations. In “Civil Unrest” the neighborhood bands together after a renegade refrigerator bandit strikes on their street. Their anger is sparked because the trash collectors had just come through. They had finally gotten their street back to some degree of normalcy. It was their small oasis in the chaos and this guy ruins it. Rose describes it like this, “We could see our curbs and sidewalks for the first time since the hurricane. The place was swept spotless. It was a time for celebration. Except for that damn smelly fridge they left on the corner, just like we said they would.” (103) Even after explaining to the man that his fridge wouldn’t be taken by clean-up crews he left it. It was this act of outright disrespect towards him and his fellow residents that really gets to Rose, and I don’t see how it couldn’t get to him.
In “Not in My Pothole” is a similar situation minus the personal touch. In this column someone has abandoned a dishwasher within the depths of a pothole. This is another instance of passing one’s own problems onto the problems of the group. Now, I completely understand and even encourage asking for help when it is needed. However, this does not fall under that category. This is an example of some person’s feeble attempt to make things better for himself at the expense of his neighbors. In Rose’s words, “Or maybe it was just the careless act of a common punk and now it’s somebody else’s problem, not his.” (161). Having this kind of attitude in any situation, let alone one as grave as this, does not solve anything.
Chris Rose echoes this idea throughout many of his columns. People need to step up and do their part to help make the situation just that little bit better. They are all in this terrible situation together and they need to lean on one another. If they don’t have each other then who else will they be able to turn to?
Friday, September 3, 2010
Welcome!
Hi everyone!
I'm Hannah and I'm a Senior English major and plan to go on and get my Master's in Elementary Education. This is my first semester back at UNH after a semester abroad in London last spring. I had an amazing time visiting a lot of beautiful places, and now I'm back to reality with actual school work to do. What's up with that?
I'm Hannah and I'm a Senior English major and plan to go on and get my Master's in Elementary Education. This is my first semester back at UNH after a semester abroad in London last spring. I had an amazing time visiting a lot of beautiful places, and now I'm back to reality with actual school work to do. What's up with that?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)